Introduction

As a manager, when you become aware that an employee has a concern about their employment or treatment by others, ideally you will deal with the problem by early intervention and informal discussion. This is the best way to avoid escalation and formal grievances.

Sometimes however, you will not become aware until a grievance has been raised or the informal approach will not resolve the problem.

When raising a grievance, employees need to explain the concerns they have in detail and give an indication of the resolution they are seeking. Please be mindful that while this should normally be in writing, some individual’s may not be able to approach it in this way and any complaint might need to be dealt with as a grievance, even it is received verbally.

It is essential not to ignore grievances or delay addressing them as this will almost certainly exacerbate the complaint and ultimately could result in an employment tribunal claim. The right to raise a grievance and to have it dealt with properly is a fundamental employment right.

Grievance procedures

Despite managers’ best efforts, it is rare for all parties to be entirely satisfied with the outcome of a formal grievance.  For this reason, a good grievance process will always start with an attempt at informal resolution.  Mediation can sometimes be a helpful intervention.

A formal grievance will consist of an investigation into the concerns, getting the perspective of all relevant parties and then a formal, confidential meeting to allow the aggrieved to put their concerns.  The person hearing the grievance will then need to make a judgement based on all of the evidence, about whether or not the grievance is upheld and if it is, any redress and next steps.  If the employee is dissatisfied with the outcome of their grievance, they have a legal right to appeal and have their grievance heard by a new panel which will ensure an independent and fair review of the case.

Grievances during other procedures

It is not unusual for an employee who is subject to a disciplinary, capability or other procedure, to raise a grievance –  often related to their perceived treatment through the instigation or management of these procedures.  Policies will vary, but our view is that where the grievance is clearly related to the procedure, it should be managed as part of that procedure and not as a separate grievance.  However, if the grievance is completely unrelated or the relates to the conduct of the person managing the procedure (e.g. that they are bullying or being discriminatory), it will probably be appropriate to deal with the issues concurrently, or in some cases, to suspend the other procedure until the grievance is dealt with.

Ill health related to grievances

Where an employee’s concerns span a period of time or escalate, they may become stressed and take time off sick.  This can lead to a ‘chicken and egg’ situation where they cannot face the grievance process but also cannot get well until it is resolved.  It is important to maintain contact with the individual, and to follow normal sickness absence procedures, but at the same time to seek to resolve the grievance and get them back to work as quickly as possible. Explore ways of managing the process that minimizes their stress.  For example, you will hopefully be able to investigate aspects of the grievance without speaking with them, if their grievance was detailed and informative and you may be able to work through their chosen representative or manage the process through correspondence.

Further HR Guidance

If you are an existing subscriber to Education HR, login to view further guidance and documents.

Log in

We’re here to help

If you are interested in expert HR advice and support, please contact us and we will get back to you.

Contact us
Lily Brown

Lily Brown

Lily is an experienced Senior HR Consultant who has a wealth of HR experience particularly in providing advice, support and training to Senior Leaders on various complex employment relation issues, in order to support school improvement. This includes disciplinary, grievance, capability, restructuring and academy conversions. Whilst also delivering training in various areas. She has worked within local Government, Education and the NHS. Lily holds a degree in Human Resources Management.